Are you sure you're not mixing them up with someone else?
Take Harry Potter - would you say there's "little" world-building in that? His Dark Materials is another very elaborate trilogy and the world-building in that one's superb. Hunger Games is also YA and it's got some of the most complex themes and realistic characters I've seen in a long long while.
Would you say the world help writing fantasy novels is "shallow"? And all of these ones I've mentioned touch on extremely deep themes - Potter has a lot to do with death, His Dark Materials is about God and religion, and Hunger Games about justice and political oppression and the apathy of society today in the face of severe human suffering.
Can you tell me any of these is "shallow" and falls in the category of "literary fast food"? My own novel is a YA and the themes are second chances, redemption, and desperation. About the evil that we see may not be what it seems and people are not as we think they are, but they're deeper than that.
Are any of these "shallow"? Should I be afraid now, because they're not shallow, that I shall not be published? I would not write anything else.
There would be no point in investing 2 years of my life to write about something I do not care about, just so I can keep it all very shallow. I do not want readers to read my work if my work was shallow - I would be far too embarrassed. Books should make people think and feel, and especially the minds of teenagers need to be nurtured so that they can grow up and become thinking, creative people.
Entertainment and depth are not mutually exclusive. Don't patronise your audience - if you try, people will know, and even if you get published you'll know you haven't given your work your best shot. You do yourself, as a writer, a disservice. You do your writing a disservice.
Write something that you're gonna fall in love with - if you the author does not or cannot fall in love with your own book, no one else is gonna. Write what you're gonna love, and you'll find someone else out there who'll love it just as much as you.
But don't refrain from writing something because you fear no one will want it. You're a writer dammit - if you won't believe in your own work and believe that the world is gonna fall in love with what you've written, you're just setting yourself up for failure because you'd have given up long before an agent takes you.
It's not that in YA you must do less world-building, but the way you write about it must be different. You can afford fewer large chunks of description, but if you write it well enough you'll be able to slip in just as much detail. It's in how you write about your world that's different between YA and adult novels, not in the depth of the world itself.
What you say is all cool and dandy, but not what the OP asked. What was asked was what teenagers like, not what they should like or could like. I have not read His Dark Materials so i don't have an opinion on it, but the Hunger Games series was a big pile of BS in more ways than i care to describe almost as bad as I am number Four wasand Harry Potter didn't involve much world building as it was all based on already existing landmarks.
If you take Hogwarts out of the equation it is all set in very real London locations. And creating a building does not world building constitute. Neither are the mechanics of magic explained or most other world building aspects for that matter. I will agree that the setting was nicely done but it was by no means a world building project.
I never once suggested writing something shallow just to make more sales.
What i said was that if what you want is a YA best seller, it should be neither very deep nor extensive in its world building.How to Write a Novel Step by Step The toughest part of learning how to write a novel is knowing where to start and how to keep on going to the end.
This section of Novel Writing Help is all about demystifying the writing process.
If you’re writing fantasy set entirely in a fictional world (as opposed to, for example, a medieval fantasy based on this actual historical era), here are 7 tips that will help you craft an immersive page-turner.
Nov 30, · How to Write a Credible Fantasy Story. In this Article: Writing Help Establishing Your Setting Making the Rules Defining Characters Writing the Story Community Q&A Do you want to write a fantasy novel, but want to make it credible, original, and distinct?88%().
Apr 08, · I was just reading another thread about how another writer here seems to be having the same problem as I am having, and someone replied, "If you want. Here is my ten-step process for writing a design document. I use this process for writing my novels, and I hope it will help you.
I used the Snowflake Method to help me write the book, and at the end, you get to see the Snowflake document I created for the book, exactly the way I wrote it. How to write fantasy - what's a fantasy novel? Fantasy is a genre or category of fiction that is about things that are generally considered to be impossible.
This includes magic, and magical creatures such as elves, dragons, .